1 - 20 of 92 Bookmarks by shinyfuryturtle
Navigation
List of Bookmarks
-
Tags
Summary
Any initial awkwardness filtered away over a hundred miles of highway as Sam thumbed through the missing witch’s diary again. Some people had secret coke habits or secret second wives, and some people had passionate, pitch black, no-kissing sex with a family member every four to six months and never talked about it. You had to find ways to cope.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 29,734
- Chapters:
- 2/2
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 124
- Kudos:
- 1,432
- Bookmarks:
- 344
- Hits:
- 18,653
Bookmarked by shinyfuryturtle
26 Jan 2026
Bookmarker's Tags:
Bookmarker's Notes
Another late seasons wincest feelings realisation despite fucking for years. Bit of angst but a happy ending. An entertaining case fic provides some levity. Yet another entry on my all time favourite wincest fic list by the amazing applecrumbledore.
Yesterday, Minnesota by Applecrumbledore.
-
Bookmarked by shinyfuryturtle
30 Oct 2025
Bookmarker's Tags:
Bookmarker's Notes
Wonderfully written with a good plot, great characterisations, lots of angst and hot sex. Discovered this fic last year (2025) but only bookmarking now as I realise this fic pops into my mind every few months.
2026: Unfortunately this fic has been deleted and the writer's works have disappeared from AO3. I do have it saved so if you want a copy please reach out to me on tumblr @shinyfuryturtle. Summary pasted below. It is just under 54K words
For You to Me Are the Only One by flowerofnettles
Classic trope, Winchester Drama version—Before the boys hit her with witch-killin’ bullets, the monster of the week puts a curse on Dean: either he has sex within five days, or his heart will give out. The catch? The curse was designed to make its target violent during sex, and
naturally Dean refuses to put anyone’s life at risk to save his own. As the fifth day gets closer, a desperate Sam makes the choice for them both, by offering (with a little help from Castiel’s angel powers) the only person he’s willing to risk at Dean’s hands: himself. Only when it
ends they’ve got bigger problems, because Sam never expected that a few nights pretending to be a stranger volunteering to take care of Dean could lead to such shocking discoveries about himself, his brother, and the strength of the bond tying their souls together. -
Tags
Summary
Sam hasn’t always been in love with Dean. He is now though, and despite his initial reservations, they’re together and they’re happy. Things are surprisingly good between them. Or they are until Dean suddenly starts to shut Sam out without explanation and Sam is driven to making a mistake that Dean might not be able to forgive.
Packed full of brother issues and lover issues and angst and jealousy and insecurity and that special kind of dysfunction that only the Winchesters can deliver. A story about a hard time in a relationship, set against a backdrop of fairly ordinary hunting jobs and nosey secondary characters.- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 26,505
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 45
- Kudos:
- 635
- Bookmarks:
- 121
- Hits:
- 12,740
Bookmarked by shinyfuryturtle
10 Sep 2025
Bookmarker's Tags:
Bookmarker's Notes
Mid-series established wincest (read the writers Blow Me 'Verse for the full development of their relationship) that hits a snag. Poor communication and poor choices leads to a lot of angst and hurting brothers. Lots of emotions in this one but a good read with a happy ending.
Put You Down for a While by rockstarpeach
-
we didn't get it right, but love, we did our best by according2thelore
Fandoms: Supernatural (TV 2005)
19 Nov 2023
Tags
Summary
It’s been minutes but Dean’s been starving for him, deprived of the depth of feeling.
“Hey, Sammy,” Dean says, weak to anything else, and watches the smile on Sam’s face, the way his face looks not contorted by grief like it had in the seconds before Dean had lost consciousness.
“Dean,” Sam says, and isn’t that the goddamn thing? Dean can’t take it a second more, the buzzing under his skin is indomitable.
He reaches forward, and Sam’s already pulling him into a hug.
Or: Sam gets to Heaven, and now they might actually have to get their shit together...
Series
- Part 1 of heaven!verse
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 34,853
- Chapters:
- 4/4
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 105
- Kudos:
- 829
- Bookmarks:
- 254
- Hits:
- 14,149
Bookmarked by shinyfuryturtle
19 Aug 2025
Bookmarker's Tags:
Bookmarker's Notes
Have already read this a bunch of times but never bookmarked before for some reason. Has to be one of my favourite heaven fics and 1st time wincest fics. Lots of angst, some tears and soulmate sex.
we didn't get it right, but love, we did our best by according2thelore
-
Tags
Summary
Sam and Dean are done. Out. Once their biggest battle was over and a last hunt almost took them out, settling down seemed like the best idea. A house of their own. Some animals. Sam even starts a garden. Sure, they're still the "freaks" they've always been. The people in town talk but their house back in the woods gives them the privacy they need and they have enough secrets to keep without having to keep them from nosy townsfolk.
Except, they find themselves taking care of a newly orphaned boy who might just be what they need to complete the life that they've made for themselves. Being fathers might not have been their plan, and they aren't exactly the type of people most would think of as fatherly types with what they've been through and the men they've had to be, but... somehow it quickly seems like this is exactly the last piece to the puzzle of the rest of their lives.Bookmarked by shinyfuryturtle
05 Aug 2025
Bookmarker's Notes
Incomplete (though not sure if abandoned) but still worth the read! Wonderfully written.
Secondhand Wolves by writerforthem
-
Tags
Summary
"You know why. I'm not leaving my brother alone out there."
Sam is dependent on Dean's touch and closeness after the wall falls - Dean's presence reminds him of why he chose to wake up, and keeps the memories at bay, allowing Sam to function.
The brothers have to face up to what happens when their Winchester codependency becomes literal, and the physical, spatial and temporal boundaries of their bond blur the line between familiar and suffocating, comforting and limiting.- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 23,934
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Collections:
- 2
- Comments:
- 129
- Kudos:
- 3,068
- Bookmarks:
- 770
- Hits:
- 64,165
Bookmarked by shinyfuryturtle
05 Aug 2025
Bookmarker's Tags:
Bookmarker's Notes
Have read this multiple times and for some reason never bookmarked it even though it is a definite fave. Takes place after Sam's wall comes down but before Bobby's death. Only Dean's touch seems to help.
Stay the Distance by lazy_daze
-
Tags
Summary
“Let me get this straight,” Dean says, and takes another sip from his cup. He needs way more coffee if he’s expected to deal with this so early in the morning.
“You – magicked up a chicken.”
“Look, I don’t know either, man.” Sam throws up his hands, helplessly. “It’s just – I haven’t been sleeping and I’ve been trying to get some more practice, and … I don’t know, conjuring up poultry seemed safer than experimenting with dark blood magic at four in the morning, you know?”
“Well, can’t argue with you there,” Dean concedes, and tilts his head to contemplate the chicken. The chicken stares back, unfazed.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 6,801
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 125
- Kudos:
- 1,281
- Bookmarks:
- 318
- Hits:
- 9,008
Bookmarked by shinyfuryturtle
23 Jul 2025
Bookmarker's Notes
Light-hearted, entertaining later seasons first time with a witchy Sam experimenting with magic. Just delightful!
Any Witch Way by merle_p
-
Tags
Summary
Canon Divergence from Lebanon, (14x13). The needle skips. A different choice is made. The song plays on.
Bookmarked by shinyfuryturtle
14 Jul 2025
Bookmarker's Notes
Beautifully written and woven with elements of canon but the story takes place entirely within Lebanonverse (Pearlverse?). Sam and Dean will always find their way back to watch other.
Deal Me Up Another Future by orphan_account (eugara)
-
Tags
Summary
What does it take to break you? What does it take to save you?
Takes place in Season 2, after John dies, before cold oaks.
Rape/Non-con, hurt/comfort
(I have had many people say they don't usually read non-con but took a chance on this and are happy they did so, why not? Take a chance. What have you got to lose?)
Includes Wincest and eventual higher rating.
Banner by: Reggie11 at LiveJournal
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 101,389
- Chapters:
- 33/?
- Comments:
- 383
- Kudos:
- 542
- Bookmarks:
- 141
- Hits:
- 26,786
Bookmarked by shinyfuryturtle
16 Jun 2025
Bookmarker's Notes
I never used to read incomplete fics but I've discovered some absolute gems that are still worth the read. And this is one of them. Read the tags but if you want angst and comfort and caretaking and the brothers rediscovering/solidifying their closeness through trauma recovery, then read this.
What It Takes by CrimzonChyld
-
I ain't no lady, but you'd be the tramp. by tehdirtiestsock (thatotherperv)
Fandoms: CW Network RPF
15 Aug 2010
Tags
Summary
a human Lady and the Tramp, with dog-like sex
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 11,153
- Chapters:
- 3/?
- Comments:
- 162
- Kudos:
- 1,010
- Bookmarks:
- 306
- Hits:
- 46,517
Bookmarked by shinyfuryturtle
23 Apr 2025
Bookmarker's Notes
Apparently this is the very first omegaverse fic ever, originally written and posted on live journal in 2010, although the term omegaverse wasn't used until almost a year later. Never finished because writer got spooked that so many people were pissed about one of the characters that meant J2 weren't OTP. Definitely worth the read though.
I ain't no lady, but you'd be the tramp by tehdirtiestsock (thatotherperv)
-
Tags
Summary
Sam has spent six weeks searching for his dead brother only to find out that Dean is a demon and he's been living it up with the King of Hell. Crowley, however, has given up on Dean and handed him over to Sam. Dean of course has no wish to be cured and would rather keep the party going. It will take a lot to persuade Sam to give up on "fixing" Dean and accept the demon as his brother, and it means being led down a dark path.
"Vermilion" starts immediately following 10x02.
Bookmarked by shinyfuryturtle
11 Apr 2025
Bookmarker's Tags:
Bookmarker's Notes
Definitely one of the darker fics in my bookmarks so read the tags and warnings but it ends on a positive note as the brothers try to heal from the recent trauma they each suffered.
Only Flesh With Its LIfe by LaMepriseFangirl
-
Tags
Summary
The Winchesters are on the road one night when they refuel at a truck stop. It is here that innocence is shattered when Dean encounters a monster of the worst kind... a human one.
It's up to John and Sammy to help Dean, little does anyone know that these are the events that shape the man he is to become.
Bookmarked by shinyfuryturtle
26 Mar 2025
Bookmarker's Notes
So heartwrenching to read but can definitely see how this night shapes them all. Fair warning, I was pretty much in tears the whole time.
The end of the beginning by devilscut
-
Tags
Summary
This could, quite possibly, go down as the most ridiculous thing he's ever done.
Bookmarked by shinyfuryturtle
24 Mar 2025
Bookmarker's Tags:
Bookmarker's Notes
A sweet and steamy exploration of sex.
Coupons by strive2bhappy
-
Tags
Summary
Dean Winchester is happy as can be. He and Sam are together again, and more importantly, working—they've got one successful trial beneath their belt, they've sorted out their latest case with a minimum of mayhem, they're on the way back to the bunker to figure out their next move. It's been a rough road, but things are looking up.
So of course now's when Sam gets into one of his moods...
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 5,743
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 58
- Kudos:
- 312
- Bookmarks:
- 78
- Hits:
- 3,452
Bookmarked by shinyfuryturtle
11 Mar 2025
Bookmarker's Tags:
Bookmarker's Notes
Amazing coda to s8e15. The episode isn't great imo but this more than makes up for it.
this bullet inside me by missroserose
-
Tags
Summary
Sam and Dean travel to the fairy realm hoping to make a deal to get Adam released from the Cage. The price: their shared secret.
Bookmarked by shinyfuryturtle
10 Mar 2025
Bookmarker's Notes
A rich, engaging tale with fantastic original characters, first time wincest and humour.
Keep This Secret by ellerkay
-
Tags
Summary
It's been a long time since things were this bad between them. Since the last time Dean decided he didn't give two shits about what Sam said. It's bad enough to make Sam cringe now, wondering how he'll ever get on Dean's good side again. If that's even possible. How does one say 'Sorry, I didn't rescue you from Purgatory'?
You don't, he thinks to himself.
Finding an empty house in the woods where hikers have been disappearing might not be the best place to finally clear the air, but it seems as if they won't have much choice once Sam gets taken and Dean is faced with just how bad Sam is dealing with their current conflict.
Bookmarked by shinyfuryturtle
09 Mar 2025
Bookmarker's Tags:
Bookmarker's Notes
Early season 8 fic in which Dean finally figures out that he's been a terrible brother to Sam. Angsty.
Show Them Our Bones by Writerforthem
-
Tags
Summary
For the past ten years, Dean has been bookmarking porn on the laptop for Sam to watch. Sam figured it would never go further than that, until one night, not long after killing Hitler, Dean decides to be brave. One thing is for sure: Dean is never going to let Sam live down the fact that porn is what brought them together, in the end. Set between 12x06 & 12x07, but not necessarily a coda.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 10,157
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 137
- Kudos:
- 1,590
- Bookmarks:
- 428
- Hits:
- 24,490
Bookmarked by shinyfuryturtle
20 Jan 2025
Bookmarker's Notes
Read this ages ago and never bookmarked it! A great later seasons first time.
With Your Dreams Untold by waywardelle
-
Tags
Summary
It's the night before Swan Song and they're on their way to Detroit. Dean knows without a doubt that everything they've been through, everything they've done and everything they've been to each other has brought them to this point. He's having a hard time coming to terms with the agreement he made to let Sam say ‘yes’ to Lucifer. This is their final night and they spend that time flashing back through pivotal moments of their life together, from birth to impending death, clinging to one another, making promises, and trying to find a way to say goodbye. Established Wincest relationship.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 29,947
- Chapters:
- 5/5
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 15
- Kudos:
- 85
- Bookmarks:
- 28
- Hits:
- 2,784
Bookmarked by shinyfuryturtle
18 Jan 2025
Bookmarker's Tags:
Bookmarker's Notes
A wonderfully heartbreaking fic set during Swan Song 5x22 as they spend their last night together.
Falling Away With You by TwinchesterAngel
-
Tags
Summary
Picks up where 'My Bloody Valentine' left off. The horseman Famine made Sam relapse into his demon blood habit, forcing Dean and Cas to lock him in Bobby's panic room again. This is my take on the fallout.
Bookmarked by shinyfuryturtle
09 Jan 2025
Bookmarker's Tags:
Bookmarker's Notes
Labelled a fix-it fic for seasons 1-5 by another user, it's not far off the mark. Forced to confront and communicate, they do. Painful yet beautiful watching them have the courage to be vulnerable.
Reset by paperstorm
-
Summary
This is a series of episode tags for 1x1 - 5x20. My original intent was to write a Wincesty tag for every episode in the whole series but obviously that did not happen. It doesn't have much of an ending as a result, but lots of emotions and love and angst along the way!
- Words:
- 391,531
- Works:
- 102
- Bookmarks:
- 141
Bookmarked by shinyfuryturtle
07 Jan 2025
Bookmarker's Notes
Amazing, insightful series by a wonderful writer who nails Sam and Dean's characterisations. Series is my headcanon and should be canon as far as I'm concerned. My only criticism is that it ends at s5. Primarily bottom Sam with the occasional bottom Dean.
Deleted Scenes by paperstorm